Nantucket restaurants

For my mind was made up to sail in no other than a Nantucket craft, because there was a fine, boisterous something about everything connected with that famous old island, which amazingly pleased me. – Herman Melville, Moby Dick

$1 - €0.8
16:59
55 °
Photo: Courtesy of Cru Nantucket

Boarding House

  • Town, American, $$$$ $$$
  • 12 Federal St.
  • Nantucket, 02554
  • +1-508-228-9622
  • Website | Email | Menu

The underground wine cellar-feeling restaurant serves homey, delicious food (Bartlett's Farm tomato salad, chicken under a brick, and softshell crab are my favorites) and is perfect for a rainy night. The terrace is great for brunch on a sunny day, and the bar works for either.

Brant Point Grill

  • Brant Point, American, $$$$ $$$$
  • 50 Easton St.
  • Nantucket, 02554
  • +1-508-325-1320
  • Website | Menu

Sunday brunch on the patio at the White Elephant's restaurant provides the best vantage for beautiful Nantucket Harbor. Bloody Marys + boats = a winning combination.

Cru Nantucket

  • Town, Seafood, $$$$ $$$
  • 1 Straight Wharf
  • Nantucket, 02554
  • +1-508-228-9278
  • Website

New this summer, it's a great, fresh take on New England classics. Cru also has prime real estate: an open-air, dockside restaurant surrounded by gorgeous visiting yachts and sailboats.

The Downyflake

  • Town, Diner, $$$$ $$
  • 18 Sparks Ave.
  • Nantucket, 02554
  • +1-508-228-4533
  • Website | Menu

There's always a wait to sit-down for breakfast at this local diner. It goes by quickly when you distract yourself with a chocolate doughnut from the take-out counter.

The Juice Bar

  • Town, Ice Cream Parlor, $$$$ $
  • 12 Broad St.
  • Nantucket, 02554

Local ice cream shop with homemade waffle cones you can smell a mile away. Order the brownie à la mode in a waffle cup or mint Oreo with hot fudge for a tasty treat.

Lola41

  • Town, Japanese, American, $$$$ $$$
  • 15 South Beach St.
  • Nantucket, 02554
  • +1-508-325-4001
  • Website | Email | Menu

Hopping and fun. Serves deliciously fresh sushi and macaroni and cheese on the same menu. The tuna burger is astounding and available at their take-out outpost, Lola Burger.

Millie’s

  • Madaket, American, $$$$ $$$
  • 326 Madaket Rd.
  • Nantucket, 02554
  • +1-508-228-8435 ‎
  • Website | Email

Laid back restaurant with something for everyone. Their quesadillas are especially good as is the tart frozen yogurt they offer from the take-out window. Located on the westernmost end of the island and accessible by bike (30 minutes from town), car, NRTA bus (15 minutes from town), or - the best - the Millie's shuttle that picks up in front of the Town Information Booth on Federal Street.

The Nantucket Bakeshop

  • Town, Bakery, $$$$ $$
  • 79 Orange St.
  • Nantucket, 02554
  • +1-508-228-2797
  • Website | Email

The island's go-to spot for wedding cakes and freshly baked Portuguese bread.

Provisions

  • Town, Deli, $$$$ $$
  • 3 Harbor Sq.
  • Nantucket, 02554
  • +1-508-228-3258
  • Website

Specialty sandwiches made with fresh ingredients. The Turkey Terrific (smoked turkey, stuffing, cranberry, and mayo) on Portuguese is a classic.

Something Natural

  • Cliff, Deli, $$$$ $$
  • 50 Cliff Rd.
  • Nantucket, 02554
  • +1-508-228-0504
  • Website

Pick up sandwiches on your way to Jetties for a beach picnic. A favorite is turkey, tomato, and Swiss on freshly baked oatmeal bread. Plus a couple of homemade chocolate chip cookies.

Instant in-box upgrade: Sign up for Fathom's newsletter.