A Few Days In

MTK A-OK: The Montauk Master Plan

by Crystal Meers
Come at me, summer.

MONTAUK, New York – Seeking the shores forever more? Yeah, you, us, and Walt Whitman.

Head to the easternmost tip of Long Island for, as Whitman put it, "nothing but sea and sky." But while you're there, you might as well soak up the sun on secret beaches, tuck in a basket of clams or two, and pretend to be really bad at foosball so you don't get run out of town by the locals. 

Where to Start

A Field Guide to the Hamptons: Mind your Ps and Qs and fedoras.
Little Black Book: Lobster Rolls on Deck: A breakdown of the best buns in town.
Fathom Guide to The Hamptons: The essentials that will get you there — and the extras that will make you never want to leave.

MTK A-OK, The Map: A fully-loaded hit list of Fathom's favorite Montauk spots of the season.

Points of Interest from West to East

161 2nd House Rd.; +1-631-668-2877 
Monday Movie Night, Thursday Bingo extravaganza, blackboard specials at the restaurant every night of the week. Cross your fingers for a bucket of chicken and a good dance party to go off at The Electric Eel (both are likely).


Melet Mercantile
102 Industrial Rd.; no phone.
Drop the metal detector and dip into this vintage treasure trove instead. Look for the garage next to the taxi stand.

Duryea's Lobster Deck
65 Tuthill Rd.; +1-631-668-2410
Summer staples (lobster roll, chips, cole slaw) served with a view of Fort Pond Bay. The gorgeous sunsets come free with dinner.

White's Drug & Department Store
95 Montauk Plz.; +1-631- 668-2994
This is where you'll buy your magazines and Advil. And maybe a beach umbrella and a tube of aloe for the day after you get sunburned.

John's Drive-In
695 Main St.; +1-631-668-5515
You thought they stopped making places like this. Awesome cheeseburgers that cost less than $5. (They're not kidding when they call it "special sauce.") Even awesomer homemade ice cream. The lines move quickly, even when they're out the door.  

Make-Shift Milk Bar
696 Main St.; no phone.
The best of Milk Bar's cookies, pies, and cake truffles. No ice cream. Sad face. Have a coffee slushie instead.

John's Pancake House
721 Main St.; +1-631-668-2383
The great breakfast debate: Mr. John's or Anthony's? The only two diners in Montauk are on opposing sides of Main Street. It's only a matter of time till there's a cook-off. Really, what's taken them so long?

The Usual Seasonal Paper

Air & Speed Board Shop
795 Montauk Hwy.; +1-631-668-0356
The place to gear up for good or just for the day.

South Edison
17 South Edison St.:  +1-631-668-4200
Belly up to the raw bar for Blue Point oysters, littleneck clams, and Lil Anna's Mary Mary's garnished with Jonah crab claw. Local farms and fisherman supply this summertime favorite.

Coffee Tauk
83 South Elmwood Ave.; +1-631-688-7007
Grab a cup of strong coffee or a creamy latte and talk amongst yourselves.

34 S. Etna Ave.; +1-631-668-3663
If you reach the point when you need a vegetable or some such healthy thing, check the chalkboard and order up.

Naturally Good Foods & Cafe
38 S. Etna Ave.; +1-631-668-9030
Juice bar, vegan bakery, Mexicatessen, and hearty, all-natural vibe.

Surf Bazaar at The Surf Lodge

Surf Bazaar at The Surf Lodge
183 S. Edgemere St.; +1-631-668-1562 
For anyone who has worn flipflops in the middle of winter, the shop is a stash of clothing and accessories for the endless summer.

474 W. Lake Dr.; +1-631-668-5671
"Bring your lunch and catch your dinner." Captain Mike's genius tagline for his half-day fishing trips had us hooked. (Touché, Captain Mike. Touché.)

Liar's Saloon
401 W. Lake Dr.; +1-631-668-9597
Don't mess with the locals. Buy them cheap beers. Let them beat you at the foosball table. Respect.

The Hideaway
364 W. Lake Dr.; +1-631-668-6592
Word on the beach is that these fish tacos are worth tracking down.

Gin Beach
Park at the end of E. Lake Dr.
Suit up. Swim out. This is one of the prettiest strips of sand on the East End.

Moby Dick's
435 E. Lake Dr., no phone
Drinks ahoy at the pop-up bar inside Rick's Crabby Cowboy Marina.

Montauk Morning

Ditch Plains Beach
Parking lots located towards the end of Ditch Plains Rd.
Take a right at the entrance and head down the beach for one of the best swim spots. Nab a taco from the Montaco taco truck (11 a.m.-5 p.m. daily, weather permitting) when hunger strikes.

East Deck Motel
40 Deforest Rd.; +1-631-668-2334
Nothing fancy. Just everything you need for a long weekend at the beach.

Turf Truck
Dirt lot at the end of Ditch Plains Rd.
Take it all in: the Airstream, the lobster rolls, the salads of the day, the picnic tables, the sheet of plywood-turned-poetry-board. Plus, you're at the beach.

The Crows's Nest Inn & Restaurant
4 Old W. Lake Dr.; +1-631-688-2077
If life's a beach then The Crow's Nest is heaven. Stay the night or just for dinner and drinks. (Sneak in a s'more by the firepit if you can.)


Fathom's Best of Montauk


See Nantucket with the kids.
Just picture what it must be like on Coney Island
Get as far away from the Hamptons as possible. (Hello, Kerala.) 

We make every effort to ensure the information in our articles is accurate at the time of publication. But the world moves fast, and even we double-check important details before hitting the road.